Pour one out

Pour one out

Another Main Ave. institution has shut its doors – Olde Tymer’s Café.

Opened in 1981, Olde Tymer’s was run for years by the Roessler family. During the pandemic, however, Olde Tymer’s ran into financial trouble. It was ultimately sold in 2021 to local chef Mark Cavalli, who started working at the restaurant during the pandemic.

Cavalli said a number of reasons went into the decision to close the long-standing corner burger joint.

For starters, the building itself (which he doesn’t own) was run down and required hundreds of thousands of dollars in renovations. In addition, over the past 10 years, Cavalli said Olde Tymer’s had acquired a bad reputation that was difficult to overcome. And, he said a lot of people who were attached to the nostalgia of Olde Tymers’ heyday wouldn’t actually come in to support it.

On top of that, Olde Tymer’s, like most restaurants these days, had to deal with the rising costs of food, which in turn required higher menu prices. Rent, he said, is not cheap in downtown Durango. And, it was difficult to hire and retain qualified staff.

“It got to the point where after this last year, I felt like it was time to let it go,” he said.

Olde Tymer’s last day serving up food was Aug. 5. Since then, Cavalli has been selling all the memorabilia, which includes some rare Snowdown throwbacks, while clearing out the space. Cavalli said it’s likely he will open a new bistro in downtown Durango in the coming months, but it won’t be under the Olde Tymer’s banner.

As for the former Olde Tymer’s location, the site of the historic S.G. Wall Drug Store, Cavalli said the property owners would like for a new restaurant to open there. (Cavalli owns the Olde Tymer’s name, and someone would need to purchase it from him.)

In the meantime, pour one out for another Durango mainstay calling it quits, following the Palace, Red Snapper, Irish Embassy, and CJ’s Diner. And long live Olde Tymers’ classic slogan, “We Cheat Tourists and Drunks.”

Top Stories

¡Vamos, Seppy!
09/21/2023
¡Vamos, Seppy!
By John Livingston

Kuss rides into history with Durango in his heart

Read More
A galaxy not so far away
09/21/2023
A galaxy not so far away
By Jonathan Romeo

Exhibit explores connections between Star Wars and Indigenous cultures

Read More
Beyond the blue bin
09/14/2023
Beyond the blue bin
By Jonathan Romeo

A trip through Durango’s recycling stream

Read More
How high?
09/14/2023
How high?
By Tom Hesse/Colorado Public Radio

New GPS system seeks to get better read on what is – and isn't – a 14er

Read More
Read All in Top Stories

The Pole

Unsolved mysteries
09/21/2023

New documentary explores why Native peoples left ancient Four Corners region.

Spinning a yarn
09/14/2023

Author John Fayhee coming to Maria's Bookshop

One dam solution
09/07/2023

California farmers open to draining Lake Powell

Home, sweet dome
08/31/2023

If you’re a home-improvement channel surfer, chances are you’ve come across some familiar scenery. For that past year, HGTV has aired “Building Roots,” a home reno show featuring Pagosa Springs-based husband and wife Ben and Cristi Dozie

Read All Stories in the Pole