Multiculturalism done right
Pixar's 'Coco' delivers deeper message in fun, vibrant package

Multiculturalism done right

In Disney/Pixar's movie "Coco," young Miquel finds himself in a land where people only exist as long as they are remembered.

Willie Krischke - 12/14/2017

It’s good to see Pixar back on its game. “Cars 3” was a cynical, empty advertisement for toys, without a doubt the very bottom of the Pixar barrel. But “Coco” recovers the reasons why I love (and faith-fully attend and review) Pixar films. It is visually stunning with a big heart and a willingness to both go for broke emotionally, while also making sure it earns every sentimental moment.

But I’ll tell you, I was worried. I’m still not sure what I think about the way Disney/Pixar is looking to other cultures for storytelling material. To be frank, I’m torn, and it makes me a bit nervous every time. It is fun to see non-white characters and non-European cultures on the screen, in all their beauty and variety, and I am glad that both white and non-white children will have heroes with brown skin and dark hair.

On the other hand, these movies can feel like Western tropes dressed up in the clothes and customs of other cultures. 

For example, “Coco” is the story of Miguel, a young Mexican growing up in a proud family of shoemakers. Music is forbidden in his family, because of a great great grandfather who was a musician and deserted his family to pursue his career. But Miguel has a secret love and talent for music, and finds his family identity too constricting. This basically makes “Coco” a “follow-your-dream” type of story (as was “Moana”), and that particular genre is rooted in the Euro-American immigrant experience – the tension between honoring your roots and striking out to do something new. (Yes, I’m aware that Latinos immigrate to America, but their reasons – and their story – are often different from European immigrants.)

In pursuit of his dream to become a famous musician like his great great grandfather, young Miguel (voiced by Anthony Gonzalez) lands himself in the land of the dead, inspired by Dia de los Muertos. It’s visually striking, amazing animation, an intricately layered underworld inspired in part by Mayan architecture, and in part by the ofrenda altars that play a central role in the story. This land functions as a subset of the land of the living; people here only exist as long as they are remembered; when they are completely forgotten by the living, they fade into nothingness. On one day of the year – Dia de los Muertos, of course – they are permitted to cross a flower bridge into the world of the living and visit their families, but only if their photo occupies someone’s ofrenda.

Trapped among the dead, Miguel must seek out his great great grandfather and get his blessing in order to return to the land of the living. To do so, he enlists the help of a scrappy skeleton named Hector, who is just trying to get someone to remember him. There’s a twist that’s pretty easy to guess, and as a result, Coco sags a little in the middle with the weight of the familiar. A lesser movie would have played this out to its predictable conclusion, but “Coco” has a few more tricks up its sleeve. This is the extremely rare film where the third act really is the best. Pixar doubles down on character development and conflict even as it ramps up toward the climactic resolution of its central problems.

And along the way, “Coco” manages to invert that “follow your dream” formula. The villain, after all, is a guy willing to do whatever it takes to maintain his reputation. He is beloved by his fans but acts, behind the scenes, like he has no relatives. You wonder who remembers him and who only remembers the fame-distorted image of him. And while Miguel’s dreams and desires are important, he learns that they are not as important as his responsibilities to his family. And when he honors those, doors open for him that otherwise would remain closed. It’s a both/and solution to an either/or problem. “Coco” thrills with its visual invention. But its core elements – dead relatives whose choices and character still influence who we are and who we will become; the power of loving memory; the importance of honoring those who have gone before us – is both timeless and increasingly relevant to a white, Euro-American audience. Many white people like myself have so little sense of history; we are far more concerned with the future than the past, and cut off from a key piece of our identity as a result.

I think “Coco” is multiculturalism done well. I expect that Latin Americans will enjoy this movie because they see their culture and values portrayed on the big screen in a respectful and engaging way. I hope that non-Latinos will see a rich culture that has much to teach us about what it means to be human and part of a family that extends long before and long after our own lifetimes. “Coco” brought a tear to my eye because it created space for me to reflect on my own family, the people I remember with love and affection, and the ones that tragically have been forgotten.

Top Shelf

Indie rock'n'roller, uptown jazz and math rock
Indie rock'n'roller, uptown jazz and math rock
By Chris Aaland
02/21/2019

When did you first discover Martha Scanlan? For me, it was around 2001, when her old-time bluegrass outfit, Reeltime Travelers, began appearing on the festival circuit, playing the old Silverton Jubilee, the Durango Bluegrass Meltdown, Telluride Bluegrass and RockyGrass.

Heart strings, infamous strings & belly laughs
Heart strings, infamous strings & belly laughs
By Chris Aaland
02/14/2019

Life sure keeps you busy. My boy, Otto – fresh off being named to the honor roll! – turned 12, requiring a night out with the family Tuesday.

Boring Bowl, The Dude sells out & Hillbilly Poetry
Boring Bowl, The Dude sells out & Hillbilly Poetry
By Chris Aaland
02/07/2019

Now that was boring. Not only was Sunday’s Super Bowl the lowest scoring ever, but it was my first completely sober Super Bowl since 1986 ... and I was 17 then.

Snowdown's greatest hits
Snowdown's greatest hits
By Chris Aaland
01/31/2019

Unless you live in a cave, you’ve probably noticed a number of people flying about downtown dressed in masks and capes. It’s Snowdown week! This year’s theme is “Get Your Comic On,” which brings a bit of Comic-Con to our quaint mountain borough.

Read All in Top Shelf

Day in the Life

Earth tones
Earth tones
By Stephen Eginoire
02/21/2019

Tired of looking at harsh, reflective white? Then feast your eyes on the gentler, subtler hues of winter. For most, winter brown is an acquired taste.

Rollin' a fattie
Rollin' a fattie
By Stephen Eginoire
02/14/2019

The 5th annual Silverton Whiteout kicked off last Saturday as fat bikers from ’round the hood and beyond rode lap after lap on a well-groomed 9.2-mile loop for 10 straight hours.

A bunch of comics: A look at the Snowdown that was
A bunch of comics: A look at the Snowdown that was
02/07/2019

Well, there you have it folks. Durango’s 41st Snowdown celebration is in the bag. 

Taking off the Chill
Taking off the Chill
By Stephen Eginoire
01/31/2019

With the shortest days of year in the rearview mirror, the sun a little higher and the days a little longer, our orientation toward the sun favors less chilly walks in the great outdoors, and certainly less GoreTex (on a nice day, of course.)

Read All in Day on the Life